Loose Leafs: What A Mess

Home » Featured Post » Loose Leafs: What A Mess

What a difference 11 games can make. The Leafs are now 1-9-1 in their last 11 games and winless in their past 8.

Jim Hiller may be the quickest coach to be placed on the “hot seat” in Maple Leafs history.

Gavin McKenna can’t find a shift in OT (the team has gone to OT 4 times this year and last spring’s #1 overall pick has exactly 0 seconds played in the extra frame).

Sergei Bobrovsky has allowed 3 goals or more in 13 of his 14 starts.

Anthony Stolarz looks better when he’s between the pipes, but the defense in front of him is so porous that he has little chance on most nights. Still, he has 5 of the teams 8 wins to his name in just 10 starts and it appears that he will get more work moving forward than his former mentor. Let’s hope that his body can withstand the grind. If it can’t the team will have no other choice but to ride Bobrovsky come hell or high water.

Artur Akhtyamov, the heir apparent between the pipes, isn’t having the best season so far in the AHL. Even if he was, would you risk spoiling a good goalie prospect by calling him up and playing him ahead of his Russian hero? It wouldn’t be unheard of for a rookie goalie to arrive on the scene only to save a teams season, but that’s rare and that wouldn’t be the likely result if they turned to him at any point during the season.

Dennis Hildeby hasn’t lost a game in regulation this season, has the best SV% on the team and lowest GAA to boot. Maybe he can be a solu… wait, they dealt him (and added a 3rd and 4th round pick, I might add) for the cap dump that is Nick Paul after Paul produced just 15pts in 51 games with Tampa Bay. At the moment he has 7pts in 24 games, which puts him on pace for 15pts in 51 games and/or 25pts in 84 games. He has spent enough time alongside the likes of William Nylander and Gavin McKenna, as well as the 2nd PP unit to expect more than that.

GM John Chayka gambled on a bounce back season for Paul, just as he did with Bobrovsky, but those bets simply aren’t panning out. That’s not to say that all of his signings and acquisitions haven’t contributed in a positive manner. Darren Raddysh is on pace for over 50pts, which may not live up to the 70pt season he had last year in Tampa, but it isn’t terrible either, especially considering the fact that he hasn’t been horrible defensively. Jack Roslovic is having a career year, Kirill Marchenko was doing well until he got injured and his absence from the lineup coincides with the teams losing streak, which is likely more coincidence than anything, but still worth noting. Some depth pieces, such as Colton Sissons, Brandon Duhaime, Teddy Blueger and my personal favourite, Zack MacEwen, have been good to great.

In fact I would argue that, besides the coach and Bobrovsky, much of the fault for this terrible season to date lies at the feet of the players that were already here. John Tavares has lost a step (time comes for all of us), Oliver Ekman-Larsson simply can’t play within this system (if you could call what they’re doing a system), Jake McCabe is likely in the same boat, Morgan Rielly is his usual defensively irresponsible self, Troy Stecher is a bottom pair defender being asked to play above his head and William Nylander… well, Nylander is exactly what he has always been. The only real difference is that Leafs Nation is finally asking him to be a responsible player. Too little, too late in my opinion.

What a mess, to say the least. So, what options do they truly have?

Auston Matthews, William Nylander, Morgan Rielly, John Tavares (aka, The Core)

There are now questions about Auston Matthews’ future as a Leaf, which is fair, even if William Nylander should be the player to go. Nobody wants to stick with a team that simply keeps losing, but at the same time tanking for high end players in the draft isn’t an option for the team. The Leafs don’t own their 2027 and 2028 1st round picks, which means finishing as high in the standings as possible is their only real option right now. Like it or not, having Matthews in the lineup is only going to help the team win more games.

In addition to that, if the team and Matthews were to have a meeting today and decided that it is time to part ways, it would take months for a deal to come together. An Auston Matthews trade would be complicated and even if the aim were to add 3-4 roster players, the timing would allow a push for the playoffs. Trading the Captain is a deal that would most likely happen before the 2027 NHL Entry Draft, with the trade deadline being the absolute earliest date, but even that could be considered rushing it in my opinion.

Remember, this timeline is based on that meeting happening today. That meeting is still a ways off, which would make any Matthews trade during this season even more remote.

William Nylander is nearly in the same situation. He has a full NMC and any trade for him may be complicated considering the fact that he would have a list of approved teams. I would consider this conversation between the team and player to be much more likely if things don’t turn around quickly, but, as Elliotte Friedman said, it could be a touchy subject:

My favourite scenario is simply trading Nylander for blueline help. Where? When? Who? Those are difficult questions to answer, but make no mistake, Nylander is a high end offensive player that could return a very good defender if one were to be made available.

John Tavares being dealt would simply open a hole at centre that the organization can’t backfill internally. He has regressed offensively this year, but I would also argue that his production and contract are fine. He simply needs a reduced role and to find chemistry withe some linemates.

Lastly, Morgan Rielly is in a cap dump situation still. He has had a decent start to the season offensively (0G, 12A, 20GP), yet he still has 3 more seasons after this one on his contract, which could be tough to move.

All of this is to say that, unless they can convince William Nylander to waive his NTC, there is likely no immediate help coming via trading the core group.

The Move That Generally Happens First

So, fire the coach? Besides the fact that he hasn’t been here long, there is no reason to avoid handing Jim Hiller his walking papers. He appears to be in over his head. He has no answers to the issues faced by the team. I find it harder to find positives within his coaching than anything, honestly.

The biggest issue I see with firing Hiller is that the team and more specifically John Chayka and Mats Sundin, would likely make an even worse decision on their second shot at a good bench boss. Daniel Alfredsson is very possibly the next man up internally, which is concerning because we have to assume that Sundin would fight to hand him the keys. John Gruden may be the better option among the current staff, but he may also be the wrong option.

Externally it was rumoured that Patrick Roy had a fantastic interview with the team and some believed that he was the frontrunner for the position at some point. Joe Pavelski was also in the mix and while it seemed imprudent at the time to go with a head coach without any experience, if the team is considering a rebuild then it may be worth circling back around to Pavelski. Lastly, Dallas Eakins, who is the head coach and GM of the Adler Mannheim of the DEL was interviewed, but it’s unclear if he would still be an option at this time.

None of those players would be at the top of my list.

Bruce Cassidy? He has the pedigree. He’s a proven winner. He’s hard on players. This team doesn’t deserve a players coach right now. If they went in this direction I wouldn’t argue, but anybody that has read anything I’ve wrote before knows the coach I want.

John Tortorella.

Is there a coach in the modern era that holds players accountable more than Tortorella? The same coach that healthy scratched Sean Couturier one month after he was named Captain of the Philadelphia Flyers is exactly what the Leafs need right now. Tortorella isn’t an old re-tread that the game has passed by. He brought the Vegas Golden Knights to the Stanley Cup Final last season, showing that he can still coach a team that is willing to buy into his systems. In other words, he’s an old re-tread that still has some tread left. Literally the only player that I would consider incapable of playing for Tortorella in Toronto is William Nylander, which should also been seen as a positive, considering this…

My favourite scenario is simply trading Nylander for blueline help. Where? When? Who? Those are difficult questions to answer, but make no mistake, Nylander is a high end offensive player that could return a very good defender if one were to be made available.
– Some guy from earlier in this rant

Fire Jim Hiller today and hire John Tortorella tomorrow? William Nylander will request a trade before Christmas.

If you ask me, this is simply the only move to make. This team is failing to a degree where they are barreling towards a rebuild. The team can either request trades because they’re playing poorly, or they can request trades because they’re being told they’re playing poorly by Tortorella. So, honestly, whats the harm in hiring a solid coach that tells it how it is?